rfid Electronic label-form comparison: non-dry glue, ceramics, anti-metal and active option selection
When choosing RFID labels, face non-dry glue, ceramics, anti-metals, four source forms, many people are stuck in their first model -- from a few centimetres to hundreds of dollars, reading distance from a few centimeters to a hundred metres, and not having the right data on the surface. The core test is three: what's the sticker, how far to read distance, where is the budget and size? Three pairs, four patterns are clear.
Differences in form and rationale
First, the four forms are different in nature.
Non-dry glue tagsIt's the largest type of RFID, structured as a layer + chip + antenna + bottom paper, essentially soft film labels, torn on. It's an passive design, which is powered by electromagnetic wave-activated chips from a reader and then retransmitting data.
Ceramic TagsIt is a hard-labeled one-size-like hull of chips and antennas, which are wrapped in the clasps of ceramics, with a small square or coin.
Anti-Metallic TagsIt is also passive, but there is an additional layer of insulation material or iron oxygen compartment to isolate interference with electromagnetic waves from the metal surface. The normal non-dry glue directly adds data to the metal surface and allows for steady reading with a further layer.
Source TabThe internal button or lithium cell, which is active in sending a signal to the reader, can be read at a distance of several dozen metres directly from an passive 10-metre scale or even hundreds of metres. The cost is larger size, higher price and life of the battery.
Cost comparison
Four forms of prices vary significantly, but the "price" behind a unit price is different.
The unit price for non-dry glue labels is usually between 0.3 and 3 metre, looking at chip types (HF ISO 14443, UHF ISO 18000-6C) and antenna processes. The larger the lot, the lower the tens of thousands of starters, the more useful logistics projects are.
The price of ceramic labels is more in the range of $3 to $20 per unit, looking at size, temperature-resistant grade, and sealing. It is expensive in materials and wrapping, not the same type as chips - chips and passive tags.
The price of anti-metallic labels is between 2 and 15 yuan, which is 3 to 8 times more expensive than the average dry glue on the same size.
The source label is the most expensive one, with a unit price of 30 to over 200 dollars, and the cost of batteries and maintenance costs, which significantly exceeds the total cost of the TCO.
The budget logic is simple: large, close — non-dry glue; small, environmentally sustainable — ceramics; medium mass, surface — metal — resistant; distance must exceed 10 metres or require a proactive report — to be considered for availability.
Read Effect to Performance Difference
Form is wrong and the effect may be different by an order of magnitude.
The reading distance of non-dry glue labels varies with frequency and size: HF (13.56 MHz) typically 3-10 cm, UHF (860-960 MHz) can be small in size from 1 to 3 m, large in size from 5 to 8 m. Put it on paper boxes, fabric, wood, plastic surfaces are most stable.
The ceramic labels read distance and draw in undry glue, but because the antenna is sealed up in a stereo, radiation efficiency is usually better, with 3-8 meters being common. The advantage is stable -- high temperature, oil pollution, no dry glue under rain, ceramics are not affected.
The metal label reads distance (1-10 meters) and is close to the size of the general label, but it's only possible to "take" this distance by placing a metal surface -- the plate is wasted on its design. It is stored in the cabinet, in the tray, in the metal container, in the metal asset.
The active label reading distance is a crushing class, which is common for 10 to 100 metres depending on the power of the launch and antenna design. It achieves long-range mass count, vehicle identification, and human positioning, which cannot be done by passive programs.
The project is based on a simple detail: reading distance can be influenced by the ability of readers, antenna gain, interference around them, and installation at a high level. The plant’s trademark often shows distances in an open and undisturbed environment, with a real scene of five to seven percent off.
Apply scene contrast
The four forms correspond to a typical set of scenarios.
Non-dry glue tagsThese scenes are not metal, within 5 metres of reading distance, and with a large number of single stickers and cost-sensitive.
Ceramic TagsPower equipment inspection (voltage transformers, switchboards), outdoor valve marking, gas graft traceability, recycling asset management, high temperature antigens for medical devices.
Anti-Metallic TagsThe key word for the scene is "metallic."
Source TabVehicle identification (no parking), container tracking, long-range location of persons (mines, sites), large asset inventory (airport baggage, railway vans). Data are required to be reported remotely or on a proactive basis.
Borders require special attention: aluminium plume packaging, liquid bottles, metal shelves - these semi-metal or non-metallic but near metal surfaces - are recommended for small batch measurements and the reading rate on these surfaces will decrease significantly.
The type of pit that you're always stepping on.
Many of these pits have been encountered.
Pipe one: no dry glue to metal.And the result is completely unreadable, or only if you have a reader on it, and the count is extremely inefficient. The solution is two -- to change metal labels, or to add plastic cushions (at least 5 mm thick).
Pocket II: Think of metallic labels as "anything."It is designed for a flat metal and the reading rate on the arc (pipes, side of metal drums) is reduced by more than 30%. The arc scene is selected for flexible anti-metal labels or foreign packaging.
Pipe III: Overuse of active labels.There is no need for batteries to cover the needs within 10 meters, and there are new ones in 5-7 years, with maintenance costs exceeding one-time tag input.
Pitfall 4: Overlooking reader and tag protocol compatibility.HF and UHF are two systems, with no consistent reading of the reader and label frequencies; UHF also has different regional bands (840-845 MHz and 920-925 MHz in China, 902-928 MHz in North America), which require confirmation for cross-regional use.
Cat Five: Only the unit price of the label is not the total cost.The installation of metal-resistant and active labels (chick, glue, stub) and maintenance hours are much higher than the direct tore-up of non-dry glue.
Pipe Six: The ambient temperature does not match the chemical tolerance.Ceramic tags handle high temperatures well, but some inexpensive models use ordinary epoxy encapsulation that becomes brittle and cracks below -20°C. Check the specific datasheet.
Selective thought and landing path
Put these dimensions on one, and press four steps.
Step One: Identify the Item the Tag Will Be Attached To.Metals/non-metals/liquids/high temperature/outdoor - this is the first fork. The metal surface is directly locked against metals, and the rest goes down.
Step two: Define the distance to read.Within 3 m, the reader works in-field - non-dry glue; 3 to 10 m requires a bulk inventory - anti-metal or ceramics; or more than 10 metres or has an active reporting demand - is available.
Step three: Economics.For runs above 10,000 units when unit cost matters, choose high-volume adhesive tags. For hundreds to a thousand units where a higher unit cost is acceptable, choose ceramic or on-metal tags. For small quantities requiring long-range reads, choose active tags, but account for battery replacement costs.
Step four: Small batch measurements.After the selection of the form, at least 20 to 50 samples are measured in the physical environment - the reader type, a tablet, the manner of installation, the surrounding electromagnetic environment is simulated and the order is re-sized.
Shanghai Zejie has conducted comparison tests in manufacturing, warehouse logistics, and energy-sector inspections. Results mostly align with the applications listed above, but exceptions do come up. One factory had wire-mesh metal racks, for example, and rigid on-metal tags did not conform as well as flexible tags, making them noticeably harder to read. Only field testing can reveal these details. We make it standard practice to use the first three steps to shortlist one or two tag formats, then test them on site.
Simple End
Select the RFID label form, which is not technically "best" but "best match." It solves 80% of the routine scenes without dry glue, and the ceramics against the environment, anti-metal eating surfaces, has a source of distance problem solving. These four forms and adhesion, distance, budget alignment, and then another round of field measurements, basically locking in the model.

Ms. Lei
Mr. Pang