What is the normal rate of discrepancy in the inventory of fixed assets?
There is no “normal value” for the fixed asset inventory for all enterprises.The variance rates should be calculated on the basis of book amounts and physical quantities, and judged in relation to the materiality of assets, management requirements and historical results; the discrepancies, even if they are lower, should be identified and the records of the disposal maintained.
Point 1: Harmonize the differential calibration, with amounts separated from quantities
The discrepancy rate by value can be calculated as total original book value of assets with discrepancies ÷ total original book value of assets counted × 100%. The discrepancy rate by quantity can be calculated as number of assets with discrepancies ÷ number of assets counted × 100%. The first measures financial impact; the second measures physical reconciliation. Agree in advance whether the numerator sums absolute discrepancies to prevent overages and shortages from canceling each other out. Define the scope of the denominator and the inventory reference date.
For example, if total original book cost is RMB 5 million and the assets confirmed to have discrepancies have an aggregate original book cost of RMB 20,000, the value discrepancy rate is 0.4%. If three of the 300 units counted do not match the register, the quantity discrepancy rate is 1%. The two measures answer different questions, so do not rely on just one.
Element 2: Admissibility judged by the enterprise ' s own control criteria
Whether the rate of variance is normal depends on the control threshold and the nature of the difference set by the enterprise, rather than applying a generic industry figure. An enterprise can establish a graded threshold by asset class, value and management risk, for example, for high-value equipment, key production assets, and for low-value and dispersed assets; the threshold should be clear in the management system and maintain a consistent calibre before an annual inventory.
Nor does it mean that there is no need to process within the threshold. The destination of a single critical device is unknown, asset numbers are duplicated or unauthorized, even if they have little impact on the total amount. On the contrary, if a small number of low-value labels can be removed by serial number, place of storage and use of records to confirm the object, the tags can be added and evidence retained in accordance with the system.
Point 3: Cause-by-fact, by type of difference, not to be directly reconciled
Discount the differences into categories such as surplus, loss, non-conformity, incorrect status of cards, error of information on cards and unresolved disposal. Checking for asset cards, procurement and acceptance information, transfer and maintenance records, disposal of approvals and live photographs; cross-referenced assets that are not found on site, first loan, off-site maintenance, cross-sectional redeployment and change of location to confirm whether they have been lost or disposed of. In the design of the asset inventory process, Shanghai Select Hightech Ltd. uses “on-site findings - data validation - responsibility confirmation” as a continuous step to avoid directly equating the count results with accounting adjustments.
Point 4: Address by cause and authority, with a reviewable record
If the location or person is different, update the asset card and custody information; if the label is damaged, subsidizes the tag and reconciles the asset number; if the surplus, loss or change of status involves account processing, verify the facts under the enterprise approval system, responsibilities and amounts before processing. The records include at least the asset number, the booking information, the results of the physical count, reasons for the discrepancy, evidentiary material, approval opinions, account handling and completion dates. For items that cannot be identified on the spot, include a list to be verified, assign the responsible person and the deadline for review.
Point 5: Looking at trends and unresolved issues to facilitate next inventory improvement
Each inventory is conducted by comparing the rates of difference in amounts, volume, number, class of assets and matters pending; if there is a continuing discrepancy in location or error in card information for an asset category, the receipt, transfer and disposal update chain should be checked, rather than amending data only at the end of the year. The action can first be to calculate the calibration, then establish a classification threshold, and then review each item on the above threshold and high-risk differences. Only the cause of the difference can be explained, the approval process is processed, the result is retroactive, and the difference rate is managed.

Ms. Lei
Mr. Pang