nfc rfid relationship resolution: frequency band, standard and applied boundary
RFID Knowledge

nfc rfid relationship resolution: frequency band, standard and applied boundary

PublishedShanghai Zejie Smart Technology Co., Ltd.

Technology spectrometry: NFC is a branch of RFID

A common question when choosing a solution is how NFC and RFID are related. Are they peers, or is one a type of the other? The latter. NFC (near-field communication) is essentially an RFID protocol operating at 13.56 MHz over distances of up to 10 cm. The real question is not NFC versus RFID, but which frequency band and standard meet your range, data rate, security, and tag cost needs. We'll look at each in turn.

RFID (Radio Freency Identification, Radio Frequency Identification) is divided into four groups by frequency band: low frequency (LF, 125-134 kHz), high frequency (HF, 13.56 MHz), ultra-high frequency (UHF, 860-960 MHz), microwave (2.45 GHz). NFC falls on the HFC level and uses the shortest of the HF RFID. In short, RFID is the overall term for this type of technology, and NFC is a breakdown of the consumer-level landscape. After understanding this, many options are unsettled.

Frequency band differences: distance, rate and antenna sizes

The RFID labels in different frequency bands can be read and write from a few centimetres to a dozen metres, with very different applications.

The higher the frequency, the smaller the antenna, the weaker it is, the lower the ability to bypass, and the lower the performance when you come close to metal or liquid. NFC's distance is short, on the one hand, as agreed, and on the other, for safety -- far away, and the risk of someone swiping your card through their pockets is high.

Standard system: selected sets of norms that cannot be bypassed

The same work at 13.56 MHz, NFC and traditional HF RFID does not apply the same standards.

HF RFID is commonly used by ISO/IEC 15693 (Vicinity card, reading distance up to 1 m) and ISO/IEC 14443 (proximity card, reading distance within 10 cm). On the basis of 14443, the NFC has also superimposed ISO/IEC 18092 (also known as NFCIP-1) and ISO/IEC 21481 (NFCIP-2). The latter allows NFC devices to proactively switch the three models of "read cards" and "readed" points to points, which is also what a cell phone can do, or be coded, or it can transmit the underlying causes of the document.

The main standard for the UHF RFID is ISO/IEC 18000-63, i.e. EPC Class-1 Gen-2 (Gen.2). The distribution of UHF bands across regions varies slightly: China is 840-845 MHz and 920-925 MHz, Europe and America are 860-960 MHz, so it is common to be regionally appropriate when the same label is deployed in different countries.

Each standard comes with its own ecosystem. Almost any phone can read NFC tags. HF and UHF RFID tags require dedicated readers, which are widely deployed in industrial settings. Start by asking who or what will do the reading: a consumer with a phone, or industrial equipment? The answer determines which protocol to choose.

Applicable scene: different division of labour from payment to storage

The most common NFC scenes are mobile phone payments, bus subway cards, door-barrier cards and fast pairing of equipment. These scenarios have two things in common: proximity, and "no distance from the sky."

HF RFID (non-NFC mode) is more often used in libraries, drug traceability, and single-grade security. The labels that are placed behind a library book are usually ISO 15693 protocols.

The UHF RFID is the backbone of logistics and retail. A factory that stores, labels the UHF on a tray or swinger, can read dozens of them in bulk when the forklift passes through the channel, which is one order of magnitude more efficient than a single sweep. The retail industry started to promote EPC Gen2 as a clothing item label for suppliers in the 2000s, and by now it has become widely available to most fast-fashion and commercial superproducts.

LF RFID is used mainly for animal earmarks and car key sensors. Read distance short, good penetration, and it is more stable in a wet, metal environment than high frequency.

Return to selection: If the label is to be read directly by a mobile phone, select NFC or ISO 14443; if a long-range mass count is needed, select UHF Gen2; if the environment is rich in metals, water is high and close to requirements, LF is more appropriate.

Cost and reading/writing performance

Tag costs vary widely. NFC tags, including the chip and antenna, typically cost RMB 0.30–2, depending on capacity, with NDEF storage ranging from 168 bytes to several kilobytes. HF RFID tags are in a similar price range. UHF tags can use printed antennas, bringing unit costs down to RMB 0.10–0.30 at scale.

For readers, almost all NFC readers have their own mobile phone belts at zero hardware and no hard-cost; HF and UHF require external fixed or handheld readers ranging from hundreds to thousands of dollars. Handheld UF readers are common configurations for warehouse counts.

Security, NFC, because of the short distance, the SE (Secure Element, Secure Component) chip can be encrypted at the hardware level, and the payment scene thus meets the financial level. The UHF RFID is far away, supports mass reading, is naturally not suitable for payment, but it's appropriate to do an "accompaniment count" -- security mechanisms are usually done by a back-end system.

And we've had a typical case of this: the original idea of "read all labels on your phone" and then switch to NFC, and it turns out that the efficiency of the count is down -- the NFC can read only one at a time, and the UHF can sweep one tray at a time. The final solution is to split it by scene: single-source NFC, bulk drive count, UHF.

The pits that are common in the selection.

And you're going to put "support NFC" like "support all RFID." Some readers are going to write "compatible RFID" in their propaganda, actually supporting only the 13.56 MHz segment, and they can't read it at all when they touch the UHF label.

Ignores regional frequency band differences. The UHF label is not identical in China and Europe, and projects for global deployment require a frequency switch at the end of the reader or choose to use broadband tags.

Performance loss around metal and liquids. UHF signals reflect and weaken at metal surfaces, and HF read range decreases around liquids. Specify tag placement during solution design, and use on-metal tags or foam spacers where necessary.

Confusion "read" and "write." NFC labels are read-only and write-only, and the wholesale scene is locked to read-only and avoid rewrite. The UHF tags mostly support reading and writing, but some of them need to be password-protected when writing.

NFC is the only interactive entry. NFC reads that users need to approach, but it is not realistic to pick up a mobile phone manually in a storage line and an unmanned view. Industrial scenes still depend on fixed-readers or handheld terminals.

Criteria for judgement and recommendations for action

Replace "NFC vs RFID" with "band + scene + standard" to judge, it'll be much clearer:

When we comb the program with our clients, we usually ask three questions: how far do you read, who reads it, where you stick it? Set these three answers down, and the frequency and standard naturally shrink to a very small range, avoiding a lot of interferocity in a dozen labels.